Nantwich councillor in 'Punch and Judy' debate over Crewe multi-storey car park

By Belinda Ryan - Local Democracy Reporter 13th Mar 2025

Cllr Patrick Redstone and Cllr Anna Burton (Nantwich), clashed over which party was responsible for the loss-making Crewe multi-storey car park (Ryan Parker).
Cllr Patrick Redstone and Cllr Anna Burton (Nantwich), clashed over which party was responsible for the loss-making Crewe multi-storey car park (Ryan Parker).

An Odd Rode and Nantwich councillor clashed over which party was responsible for the loss-making Crewe multi-storey car park, with one seeking assurances a decision like that can never be made again.

As revealed by the Local Democracy Reporting Service, the £11 million car park, which was funded by Cheshire East Council, made a loss of nearly £70,000 in its first six months of operation.

At Tuesday's (March 11) meeting of the economy and growth committee, Odd Rode councillor Patrick Redstone (Conservative), ought assurance members were made fully aware of any risks attached to future projects.

Odd Rode councillor Patrick Redstone (Conservative) (CEC).

Cllr Redstone said: "I remember back to the committee meeting which we held, and a series of workshops looking into the town centre in Crewe development related to the bus station, and we sought assurances of officers during one of those meetings, that the project regarding the multi-storey car park was sufficiently tied to the rest of the development."

He said those assurance were given but it turned out the assurances were dependent on the economic climate, not on a firm contract.

"When the economic climate changed, the multi-storey car park was left like a whale stranded on the beach in the middle of a scene of destruction as we had torn down the town centre and had no development to replace it," he said.

"So, I wanted to ensure going forward that a decision like that can never be made and that all the risks of a decision like that are clearly identified in these reports and brought to our attention."

Nantwich North and West councillor, Anna Burton (Labour), said she understood the car park had been built in good faith on the understanding HS2 was coming to Crewe.

Nantwich North and West councillor, Anna Burton (Labour) (CEC).

"My understanding from the car park in Crewe is it was linked to the HS2 project, which the Conservative government had guaranteed to Crewe and Nantwich at the time.

"That was that they guaranteed that HS2 would be coming to Crewe, and that car park was built in good faith.

"So any criticisms levelled at the car park in Crewe need to be firmly placed with the past Conservative government."

Cllr Redstone replied: "This is ridiculous. We were looking at the development which had a cinema and some shops attached to it, which was going to result in the need for a multi-storey car park.

"The economy changed. The developer decided it was not economically viable. It had nothing to do with HS2."

Crewe's £11 million multi-storey car park, funded by Cheshire East Council, made a loss of nearly £70,000 in its first six months of operation (Ryan Parker).

Committee chair Michael Gorman (Independent), said: "I do appreciate the Punch and Judy stuff, but I'm not sure we've got time for it."

He did then allow Cllr Burton a right of reply and she told Cllr Redstone: "It was actually a member of the Conservative party that pointed it out at a meeting I was at recently, so I think the Conservative party are very aware of where the responsibility for that lies."

READ MORE: What's on in Nantwich this weekend: Rio Gold and more.

Free frtom clickbait, pop-up ads and unwanted surveys, Nantwich Nub News is a quality online newspaper for our town.

Please consider following Nantwich Nub News on Facebook.

     

CHECK OUT OUR Jobs Section HERE!
nantwich vacancies updated hourly!
Click here to see more: nantwich jobs

Share:


Sign-Up for our FREE Newsletter

We want to provide nantwich with more and more clickbait-free local news.
To do that, we need a loyal newsletter following.
Help us survive and sign up to our FREE weekly newsletter.

Already subscribed? Thank you. Just press X or click here.
We won't pass your details on to anyone else.
By clicking the Subscribe button you agree to our Privacy Policy.